Piper PA-32-260 · NTSB accident record

Engine Sputter During ClimbWPR25LA131

A sputtering engine over Arizona, an electrical problem you'd been babysitting all flight, and a fuel selector with four positions

Date
Sunday, April 13, 2025
Time
~1:42 PM MST
Weather
VMC · clear · 10 SM · wind 250 at 12 gust 24 kt · 91°F
Location
High desert near Nogales, Arizona — climbout
Age
58
Cockpit moment

Climbing Out of Nogales — The Engine Starts to Sputter

You're in a Piper PA-32-260, climbing north out of Nogales on the last leg to Phoenix.

It's a clear, hot Sunday afternoon in the high desert south of Tucson.

The day started in Mexico, and you've been managing an electrical problem ever since.

The generator breaker acted up after departure, so you're on battery, cycling the power on and off to stretch it.

Two legs behind you now — Puerto Peñasco to Nogales, then back into the air.

Climbing through 6,300 feet, about 20 miles north of Nogales, the engine begins to sputter.

Under the wings are four tanks: a main and a tip on each side.

There's no BOTH position — the engine feeds from whichever one you select.

Only you know how much is left in each after a full day of flying.

The standard move for a fuel-fed stumble is boost pump on and change tanks.

Do you switch to a tank you know still holds fuel — or switch by feel and hope the engine picks back up?

By the numbers
831
fuel-starvation accidents
55
a year
88%
were survivable
143
lives lost in them
Explore more accidents at ClearQuery
NTSB accidents, 2011–2025
The decision

Four tanks, a stumbling engine, and only you know what's in each — how do you work the fuel?